Second pre-implementation review. Goes wider than #001 on cross-document
consistency and the two-way-door framing from ADR-009.
Finds 13 critical, 21 warning, 12 suggestion issues:
- Governance: ADR-022/023 are Proposed but specs treat them as binding;
ADR-015/002/004 (Accepted) contradict later refinements without supersession
markers
- Abort policy (ADR-016) missing from OperationContext struct; OperationEnv
trait never defined
- OperationContext.env type identity crisis (reachability set vs dispatch
trait)
- ADR-017 from_call mirror list missing error_schemas; OperationAdapter trait
stale vs ADR-022 bundle
- OQ-21 remote vault 'non-breaking' framing conflicts with ADR-019 and hides
a crate-decomposition decision; RemoteService path unvalidated
- Vault operation access policy table incomplete for security-sensitive methods
- site_password_path string-to-index mapping breaks determinism guarantee
- Two-way-door audit: ADR-022 narrowed several doors without updating OQ
classifications; 'published artifact is a contract' blind spot in framework
Includes recommended 5-pass resolution order.
glm-5.2
8f8a8a48f9