Critical fixes:
- C1: Create standalone ADR-006 file (edge type consistency),
extract from open-questions.md inline content
- C2: Convert CallResult from plain interface to TypeBox schema,
aligning with 'TypeBox as single source of truth' constraint
- C3: Add fromJSON() cycle detection specification - enforce
ADR-002 DAG invariant even on deserialized input
- C4: Rewrite consumer-integration.md Phase 4 to use ADR-005
event-append pattern instead of direct signal mutation
- C5: Fix operator precedence bug in consumer-integration.md
(missing parentheses around OR condition)
Warnings addressed:
- W1: Fix immutability claim - operation graph is 'conventionally
immutable', not prevented by API
- W2: Add EventLogProjection to reactive exports map
- W3: Add CallResult/CallResultSchema to schema exports map
- W4: Fix reactive-execution.md Level 1 error handling to use
event-append pattern instead of direct signal mutation
- W5: Remove duplicate dataFlow inference description in schema.md
- W6: Clarify ADR-006 project context (flowgraph vs taskgraph)
Suggestions implemented:
- S1: Add 'reviewed' document lifecycle status between draft/stable,
update all docs to reviewed status
- S2: Add carve-out note for analysis result types in schema.md
constraints (they are ephemeral, not serialized)
- S3: Add isComplete() and getAggregateStatus() convenience methods
to WorkflowReactiveRoot specification
Resolve all 19 remaining open questions across the architecture. Every
question now has a documented resolution with rationale:
- OQ-004/OQ-029: edgeType is a universal required attribute on all edges,
single graph per FlowGraph instance (ADR-006)
- OQ-011: No OR preconditions for v1; preconditionMode as v2 extension
- OQ-012: maxConcurrency enforced via reactive counting semaphore
- OQ-014: Unknown operationId creates node with pending status
- OQ-017: Expose common graphology traversal methods on FlowGraph (80/20)
- OQ-020: condition as Type.Unknown() with string/function documentation
- OQ-022: Identity imported from @alkdev/operations peer dep
- All other questions resolved with documented rationale
Fix three critical issues found by architecture review:
1. edgeType serialization/validation gap: document two-step validation
2. CallEdgeAttrs runtime discrimination: edgeType as runtime discriminant,
depends_on edges clarified as observability-only (not execution)
3. ADR-005 signal mutation inconsistency: explicitly distinguish call-level
statuses (event-log-driven) from workflow-derived statuses (signal-mutation)
Additional clarifications:
- dataFlow inference uses conservative strategy (defaults false)
- Conditional.test string resolution: operationName → status === completed
- Add negated field to TemplateEdgeAttrs for else-branch conditions
- Document edge key priority convention for composite keys
- Add maxConcurrency semaphore design to reactive-execution.md
Resolve the three open consequences from ADR-005 (Event Log as Single
Source of Truth) and transition from Proposed to Accepted:
1. Event log IS the call protocol event stream — not a separate type,
but an EventLogProjection interface (append/getStatus/getResult/
getEvents) over CallEventMapValue[] with an append-only contract.
2. Event log persists across template re-renders — projections recompute
against the new DAG; orphaned events stay in log for audit but don't
affect active projections.
3. Edges get dataFlow: boolean attribute on TemplateEdgeAttrs — inferred
(not manual) by GraphologyHostConfig from template expressions.
typeCompat() only runs on dataFlow: true edges. Inference rules are
precisely specified for Conditional.test, Map.over, and Operation.input.
Also resolve OQ-05 (structural containers stay transparent; aggregate
status is a projection from children) and OQ-10 (running node failure
is a FailurePolicy configuration, default continues-running).
Cascading updates to:
- reactive-execution.md: add hybrid status model (event-log-driven vs
projection-driven vs signal-mutation), EventLogProjection interface,
result projection respecting retries, FailurePolicy type
- host-configs.md: ReactiveContext now includes resultProjection and
computed results; resolved Q1/Q3/Q4
- schema.md: dataFlow attribute on TemplateEdgeAttrs with inference
rules and type checking implications
- workflow-templates.md: edge creation rules with dataFlow, result
projection in Conditional/Map, resolved Q1/Q4
- open-questions.md: all ADR-005 questions marked resolved, updated
summary table and cross-cutting themes, removed duplicate OQ-07
7 files changed, 464 insertions, 139 deletions
Proposed architecture decision to use an append-only execution event log
(call protocol events) as ground truth, with status/result/call-graph as
projections. Resolves OQ-06, OQ-07, OQ-08, OQ-09; reframes OQ-01, OQ-02,
OQ-10. Inspired by event sourcing discipline (notification vs state transfer)
and compute_graph ExecutionContext pattern.
- Replace workspace:* deps with published npm semver ranges (^0.34.49, ^0.1.0)
- Expand package.json: add description, publishConfig, scripts, engines,
devDependencies, conditional exports with types/default for import+require
- Fix tsup entry names (path-prefixed like ujsx), add target: es2022,
remove splitting:true (not used by sibling projects)
- Align tsconfig with sibling projects: add lib, noUncheckedIndexedAccess,
noUnusedLocals, noUnusedParameters, erasableSyntaxOnly, etc.
- Expand vitest.config.ts with include, coverage, and path alias
- Clarify @preact/signals-core as direct dep (not just transitive via ujsx)
- Clarify @alkdev/pubsub is a consumer dependency, not flowgraph's dep
- Fix edge key convention: document composite key format for call graph's
multi-edge-type scenario (triggered + depends_on between same pair)
- Align OperationEdgeAttrs field naming: use detail+mismatches consistently
instead of compatibilityDetail
- Add InvalidInputError to error hierarchy (referenced in flowgraph-api but
was missing)
- Fix undefined attrs.category reference in reactive-execution.md
- Remove internal drafting note from host-configs.md
- Fix ReactiveHostConfig constructor signature inconsistency across docs
- Constrain TemplateEdgeAttrs.edgeType to sequential|conditional only
