alkhttp/docs/architecture/decisions/070-from-wss-consumer-adapter.md

# ADR-070: `from_wss` — the WSS Consumer Adapter

## Status

Accepted

## Context

The alknet design named `from_wss` as a future, out-of-scope adapter
(alknet `websocket.md` §"Future"): importing a remote alk node's
operations over a WebSocket connection, mirroring `from_call`'s
pattern with WSS as the transport. It was deferred there because no
concrete consumer existed.

Extraction changes the calculus. The browser path is now
channels-over-WebSocket ([ADR-067](067-websocket-carries-channels.md)),
which means:

1. **The server half of WS-channels is being built anyway.** The
   consumer half (`ChannelClient`-over-WS) is the mirror image sharing
   the same WS↔byte-stream adapter (OQ-01) — building it later means
   re-validating the adapter independently.
2. **A deployment pattern became concrete:** a Rust process behind a
   restrictive network (outbound-only HTTPS/WSS allowed, no QUIC
   reachability) that needs to consume another node's operations. QUIC
   (`from_call` over an `alk/call` connection) and TCP+TLS
   (`alk/channels`) both require reachability the deployment may not
   have; WSS rides standard HTTPS infrastructure.
3. **alkcall provides both halves.** `ChannelClient`
   (alkcall ADR-043) is the channels consumer; `from_call`
   (alkcall ADR-028) is the same-protocol importer pattern. `from_wss`
   composes them over a WSS transport.

## Decision

**alkhttp ships `from_wss`: a consumer adapter that connects to a
remote node's WSS endpoint, runs the channels-over-WS session, and
imports the remote node's operations as forwarding handlers — the
same-protocol importer, with WSS as the transport instead of QUIC.**

- **Feature gate:** `wss = ["dep:tokio-tungstenite"]` (not default —
  a process that never consumes over WSS should not compile a WS
  client).
- **Shape:** implements `OperationAdapter`
  ([ADR-017](017-call-protocol-client-and-adapter-contract.md); record:
  alkcall ADR-022):

  ```rust
  pub struct FromWss {
      endpoint: url::Url,          // wss://host/alk/channels
      auth_token: Option<String>,  // injected via Capabilities at registration
      namespace: Option<String>,   // local-naming sugar, as from_call's namespace_prefix
  }

  #[async_trait]
  impl OperationAdapter for FromWss {
      async fn import(&self) -> Result<Vec<HandlerRegistration>, AdapterError>;
  }
  ```

- **Import flow:** dial WSS → wrap the tungstenite stream as a
  `Connection` (`Connection::from_bidi`, ALPN `alk/channels`) → run
  the consumer side of the channels session (alkcall `ChannelClient`
  machinery: install channel 0, run the client dispatch loop) →
  `services/list` + `services/schema` over channel 0 → one
  forwarding `HandlerRegistration` per discovered op (provenance
  `FromCall`, leaf, `Internal` by default —
  [ADR-015](015-privilege-model-and-authority-context.md),
  [ADR-022](022-handler-registration-provenance-and-composition-authority.md)).
- **Forwarding at call time:** each imported op's handler serializes
  the call input as a `call.requested` frame, writes it (length-prefixed
  JSON, alkcall ADR-014) into channel 0's write half, and correlates
  `call.responded`/`call.completed`/`call.aborted` by `id` via the
  pending map — identical to `from_call`'s forwarding shape, because
  the protocol is the same protocol.
- **Auth:** the WSS upgrade request carries
  `Authorization: Bearer <token>`; the token comes from
  `OperationContext.capabilities` at handler construction (the
  no-env-vars path —
  [ADR-014](014-secret-material-flow-and-capability-injection.md)),
  never from `std::env::var`.
- **Relationship to the server path:** the WS↔byte-stream adapter is
  shared with the server-side upgrade handler (OQ-01) — one
  implementation, used in both directions. The session itself is
  alkcall's (`ChannelClient` consumer half + channel 0 dispatch
  loop), not forked.

### Not in scope

- **Reconnection policy semantics** (auto-reconnect, stale
  registration invalidation): tracked in OQ-03; v1 surfaces a
  connection-drop as imported-op call failures (`INTERNAL`, retryable)
  and leaves policy to the assembly layer.
- **Serving WSS from the consumer side** — the producer side of a
  WSS session is the `HttpAdapter` upgrade route
  ([ADR-067](067-websocket-carries-channels.md)); no separate server
  type.
- **`from_wss` over non-TLS `ws://`** — plaintext WS is refused when a
  Bearer token is present unless `FromWss::allow_plaintext` was called
  explicitly (review-001 CON-03): a long-lived credential must not ride
  an unencrypted connection without an explicit opt-in. Plaintext for
  local/test use without a token stays allowed.

### Explicit session-lifetime limitation (v1)

**There is no teardown handle on `FromWss` in v1** (review-001
CON-08/CON-09): `import()` detaches the session fire-and-forget so the
imported handlers keep working off the Arc'd `CallConnection`, and
nothing closes the underlying server-side session when the assembly
layer is done with the import. Consequences, stated explicitly:

- Calling `import()` again (e.g. on a reconnect timer) stacks a second
  full WS session over the first: duplicate op names in the registry,
  and the original session is never torn down.
- v1 disposition: import **once per process**; treat the imported
  surface as live for the process lifetime. A reconnecting assembly
  layer should tear down its whole registry and re-import, accepting
  the accumulated server-side sessions until the remote times them out.
- **Close/teardown handle**: future work; there is no
  `WssSession::close` in v1 (OQ-03). The connection-drop monitor is
  however self-limiting (review-002 CON-18): once WS read EOF is
  observed, pending calls fail with retryable `CONNECTION_CLOSED`,
  registrations racing the drop are drained by a fast-fail sweep
  (50 ms interval) during a bounded post-EOF grace window (8
  consecutive empty drains), and the monitor task then ends — a dead
  import leaves no permanent task behind.

## Consequences

**Positive:**

- Consumers behind outbound-only HTTPS get the full operation surface
  of a remote node without QUIC/TCP reachability.
- The WS↔byte-stream adapter is validated in both directions by
  construction (server upgrade path + consumer path share it).
- Same-protocol import means zero translation: the remote node's ops
  appear in the local registry with their real specs and error schemas.
- A dead import (peer gone) self-cleans: after EOF the drop monitor
  fails everything pending, drains drop-racing registrations for a
  bounded grace window, and ends — no per-dead-session task leak
  scales with import count (review-002 CON-18).

**Negative:**

- One more WS client dependency in the tree when `wss` is enabled
  (`tokio-tungstenite`).
- Long-lived WSS connections behind proxies/load balancers need
  keepalive/timeout tuning — deployment concern, but worth documenting.
- Reconnection semantics are initially minimal (OQ-03); a consumer
  wanting hot re-registration must wait for or build the policy.
- Registrations landing in the pending map after the bounded post-EOF
  grace window elapses wait for the 30 s sweeper deadline instead of
  failing fast — acceptable because registration-vs-EOF races resolve
  well within the window in practice, and the mux write-failure path
  covers the rest.

## References

- [websocket.md](../websocket.md) — the channels-over-WS session spec
  (framing shared with this adapter)
- [ADR-067](067-websocket-carries-channels.md) — the server-side
  counterpart (upgrade path `/alk/channels`)
- [ADR-017](017-call-protocol-client-and-adapter-contract.md) — the
  `OperationAdapter` contract
- [ADR-014](014-secret-material-flow-and-capability-injection.md) —
  credential injection (the WSS bearer token path)
- [ADR-048](048-websocket-native-session-not-gateway.md) — why the
  consumer speaks the native session, not the gateway shape
- alkcall ADR-022 (adapter contract), ADR-028 (`from_call` — the
  same-protocol importer pattern this mirrors), ADR-043
  (`ChannelClient`), ADR-014 (framing), ADR-034/035 (channels wire)
- [open-questions.md](../open-questions.md) OQ-01, OQ-03